OpenTable recently named Oklahoma City, Oklahoma the most romantic city in America based on folks’ restaurant and reservation habits. Well, now a new report suggests that a different city should earn the title, but it’s based on a whole different criteria.

Redbox looked at data on rentals of romance and romantic comedy movies to make their determination of the most romantic city, with Glendive, Montana, a total newcomer to the list, earning the top spot this year. Coming in second is Columbus, Mississippi, which tied with Lake Charles, Louisiana for the top spot last year. 

Top Ten Most Romantic Cities, According to Redbox

  • Glendive, MT
  • Columbus, MS
  • Sherman, TX
  • Fairbanks, AK
  • Lake Charles, LA
  • Columbia, MO
  • Sioux Falls, SC
  • Lincoln, NE
  • Salisbury, MD
  • Fargo, ND