The Lancaster County District Attorney's Office has decided not to investigate Manheim Township Police Chief Duane Fisher, who pulled a gun on a motorcyclist last month. According to District Attorney Heather Adams, Fisher's actions did not meet the criteria for a criminal act. The incident occurred when Chief Fisher, off-duty and in plainclothes, attempted to stop a motorcyclist, Benny Peña-Rivera, for alleged traffic violations, including running a red light and driving erratically. Fisher reportedly drew his weapon during the stop to gain compliance from Peña-Rivera, who was unaware that Fisher was a police officer.
The decision not to pursue criminal charges was based on a review of surveillance footage, police reports, and other evidence. Adams stated that Fisher was acting within his capacity as a police officer and lacked the criminal intent necessary for charges. However, the Manheim Township Police Department is conducting an internal investigation to determine if Fisher's actions were consistent with department policies and best practices.
Peña-Rivera, who pleaded guilty to several traffic violations, expressed a desire for accountability, stating, "If it wasn't for that video, nobody would actually believe what I was saying because it was my word against his." Chief Fisher is currently on paid administrative leave, and Senior Lt. Brian Freyzs is serving as the acting police chief during the investigation.
The internal investigation will assess whether Fisher's use of force was appropriate, with township officials remaining tight-lipped about the ongoing inquiry. Residents of Manheim Township have been invited to share their concerns at an upcoming public event with township commissioners.